Skip to content
Brief Security & Trust ·

UN talks on 'killer robot' rules end with only a deal to keep talking

After a week in Geneva, countries agreed to discuss options for rules on autonomous weapons.

In brief
  • UN diplomats in Geneva agreed only to start discussing options for rules on autonomous weapons. They set a two-year window to propose rules.
  • The Red Cross had asked for binding rules within a year. Russia, Israel and the US were the main obstacles, according to NPR.

The Verge reported on 21 November that UN diplomats ended a largely fruitless week in Geneva on rules for autonomous weapons, often called "killer robots". They agreed only to start discussing options. Before the talks, the International Committee of the Red Cross had urged that legally binding rules be drafted within a year. The UN secretary-general and Pope Leo backed that call. Countries instead gave themselves two years to propose rules.

The Verge says talks on which rules to adopt, and how to enforce them, will likely run well past those two years. Some rules may also stay optional. The Verge cited NPR, which named Russia, Israel and the US as the main obstacles. NPR said Russia stalled the first day by objecting to the agenda. It said the US then proposed five years to discuss nonbinding, optional guidelines. The sources do not say what the rules would cover, which countries want binding ones, or when any deal could come.

Aid groups and some countries want firm rules, The Verge said, because semi-autonomous weapons and drones have caused many civilian deaths in Ukraine, Gaza and Sudan. For people who build or buy software used in such systems, no binding international rule has been drafted yet. The talks so far have set only a timetable for proposals.

A WebPulse Brief: a short report of an important event, written by the WebPulse Newsroom with AI assistance and checked against the reporting below. When there is more to explain, we follow up with a full story. How we use AI.

Reporting: The Verge.