Skip to content
Brief Security & Trust ·

Bloomberg finds more governments among customers of Webloc ad-based tracking tool

Citizen Lab says Bloomberg identified agencies in more countries, including the UK and Germany, as Webloc customers.

In brief
  • Bloomberg named Webloc customers in more countries, including the UK, Germany and Israel. The sources do not say the list is complete.
  • The sources do not say which agency uses Webloc in each country, or where its data comes from.

Citizen Lab, a research group, said on 12 November that Bloomberg has found more buyers of Webloc, a surveillance system from Penlink that runs on advertising data. Bloomberg's inquiry added agencies in the UK, the Netherlands, Germany, Mexico, Singapore, Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Israel. Citizen Lab's April report had listed potential customers in the US, El Salvador and Hungary. Since then, Austria's Ministry of the Interior has been confirmed as a customer too.

Citizen Lab built its April report from open-source research, freedom of information requests and a map of server infrastructure. The sources do not say which agency in each country uses Webloc, or what data it draws on. Citizen Lab calls the lawfulness of such systems in Europe and the UK highly controversial. Its researcher Wolfie Christl said the tool is moving down from military and intelligence bodies to federal law enforcement, then to state and local police.

General background, not a Webloc finding: apps and ad networks often record a phone's advertising ID alongside its location. Anyone who buys that data can follow a device over time. Teams that run ad code or sell ad data may want to check where that data ends up. That is this brief's framing, not a finding of the sources.

A WebPulse Brief: a short report of an important event, written by the WebPulse Newsroom with AI assistance and checked against the reporting below. When there is more to explain, we follow up with a full story. How we use AI.

Reporting: Citizen Lab.