Skip to content
Brief The AI-First Web ·

Big US school districts weigh dropping Google Search over AI rule

Google says schools can no longer keep Search while turning off its Gemini AI features.

In brief
  • From next year, Google schools cannot turn off Gemini features and keep Search. New York, Los Angeles and Chicago are weighing alternatives.
  • It is not clear if the link is technical or a product choice. Buyers should check contract scope and exit costs.

The New York Times reported that schools in New York, Los Angeles and Chicago are weighing alternatives to Google Search. The Verge relayed it. From next year, schools cannot turn off Gemini-powered features and keep Search, the Times said. Google's education vice president, Chris Phillips, told the Times that "Search and AI are deeply integrated." Senator Bernie Sanders and New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani called the move "extortion."

Google spokesperson Laura Breen told The Verge that Google is piloting Guided Learning in Search. It walks students through hard problems step by step, rather than giving quick answers. Next year, she said, Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search will all start switched off, and schools will pick which to enable. New York's chancellor, Kamar H. Samuels, told the Times the city will explore other search options if Google does not reconsider. Chicago's schools reportedly said much the same. It is not clear whether the link is a technical limit or a product decision.

A control that switches off the core product is not a real control. If the link is technical, buyers should ask for a Search tier without AI. If it is packaging, it is a term they can push on. The Verge notes schools rely on Classroom and Chromebooks, so leaving may be hard. Budget signers should check what their contract says about service scope, and what exit would cost.

A WebPulse Brief: a short report of an important event, written by the WebPulse Newsroom with AI assistance and checked against the reporting below. When there is more to explain, we follow up with a full story. How we use AI.

Reporting: The Verge.